75
drank Creamy Eggnog by Butiki Teas
5272 tasting notes

Sipdown!! (167)

Confession time!! I do not like eggnog. I only ever had it once because some guy randomly hitting on a friend in a residence cafeteria tried convincing her that eggnog was so amazing she had to go up to his room to try some right away. She did not but obviously we were all very curious as to what this “gift from the gods” tasted like and so we walked over to the grocery store and picked up a carton. We all tried a little and the rest got poured out because we hated it. That was my experience with eggnog and it was not pleasant. Consequently, this tea didn’t really appeal to me (especially since Stacy tends to nail her flavors and I feared it would actually taste like eggnog). With that said, so many reviews compared this to vanilla ice cream and other tasty treats that I (1) started to become interested in this tea and (2) I started to question if the eggnog I tried was not a very good representation of what eggnog is meant to taste like. Luckily, Roswell Strange was kind enough to send me a sample to try and as fast as it arrive, it left. I am pleased to say that I am actually enjoying this cup. It is creamy and sweet and tastes a bit like vanilla bean ice cream with a dash of eggyness. However, the flavor was more subtle than I anticipated and I found myself wanting it to be more dominant and in-your-face, rather than timidly hiding in the cup. All in all, not bad and so I am happy that I was able to try it out. Thank you Roswell Strange!!
Preparation
180 °F / 82 °C 4 min, 0 sec
VariaTEA

Apparently Steepster will not listen to my formatting and insists on making this post one giant paragraph instead of several smaller ones.

OMGsrsly

If it’s the custard you’re not a fan of, you can do a steamed milk (or microwaved!) with a grating of fresh nutmeg, a drop of vanilla, and some sugar. Maybe a dollop of dark rum or other alcohol as well. :)

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

People who liked this

Comments

VariaTEA

Apparently Steepster will not listen to my formatting and insists on making this post one giant paragraph instead of several smaller ones.

OMGsrsly

If it’s the custard you’re not a fan of, you can do a steamed milk (or microwaved!) with a grating of fresh nutmeg, a drop of vanilla, and some sugar. Maybe a dollop of dark rum or other alcohol as well. :)

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

Profile

Bio

My cupboard has grown exponentially since joining this site and I have a lot to share. Feel free to snoop through my cupboard and message me if anything interests you – I am always happy to swap!

For me, flavored teas are definitely my sweet spot. I will most often reach for black teas and rooibos or honeybush blends but I do keep some flavored whites and greens around for when the mood strikes. I have a few herbals/tisanes but most of the time I find myself disappointed by them as they often smell deliciously sweet and then end up tasting tart/sour. I have a little bit of an aversion to pu’erh and oolong teas. I am also wary of florals, earl greys, and chai teas. I do not like overpowering citrus flavors nor do I usually like hibiscus, licorice or chamomile. I love dessert teas – caramel, vanilla, toffee, cookie, cream, and other sweet flavors make me smile. Fruits like strawberry, peach, mango, and pineapples will often catch my attention as well.

I have also realized that although I really enjoy adding frothed milk to some of my teas, if I do not like the tea with zero additives (just in plain water without milk or sugar), I probably won’t drink it. The one exception is flavored matchas which I will happily drink in cold milk if I do not like it mixed with hot water. My theory is if the tea can’t stand on its own then it is not for me and I will more than likely try to swap it out for something else.

Tea Ratings Guide (as of December 10, 2017)
90-100 Teas I NEED on hand at all times
80-89 Teas I want to keep around for a cup every now and then
70-79 Teas I am glad I have around and can experiment with but probably don’t need more than what’s in my cupboard
60-69 Teas I would not turn down a cup of from a friend but that would probably be enough
50-59 Teas I can see why someone would enjoy but are not for me
Under 50 Teas I really did not like and most likely got dumped

Location

Waterdown, Ontario

Following These People

Moderator Tools

Mark as Spammer